Why hagrid expelled

It may simply be that someone without a magical education cannot be trusted with a wand. This would explain why home-schooled children would be allowed to have wands — they can be trusted with wands because they are still getting a proper magical education. A student who was originally at Hogwarts, and then expelled, will likely not have the opportunity to get a proper magical education.

Indeed, in Hagrid's case he had no family to help him or otherwise provide him with an alternative magical education. In fact, we could even argue that if an expelled student would get an alternative education e. This would also explain why Fred and George were allowed to keep their wands and use magic.

They left Hogwarts in their seventh year, and towards the end of that year itself. They already had a magical education so there was no reason to not trust them with wands. Perhaps it is thus possible that even if a student was formally expelled , his wand would not be destroyed if he was far enough into his education.

Harry does receive a follow-up letter which might be thought to indicate that the wand-snapping is separate from the expulsion:. Further to our letter of approximately twenty-two minutes ago, the Ministry of Magic has revised its decision to destroy your wand forthwith. You may retain your wand until your disciplinary hearing on 12th August, at which time an official decision will be taken. Following discussions with the Headmaster of Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, the Ministry has agreed that the question of your expulsion will also be decided at that time.

You should therefore consider yourself suspended from school pending further inquiries. It might seem as if the letter is saying that the decision on wand-snapping will be independent of the decision on expulsion. However, it is possible that that it is actually affirming the correlation between the two.

It is only because the expulsion is being reconsidered that the wand-snapping is being considered. In fact, if Harry is not expelled then he will necessarily need a wand. If Harry's expulsion is upheld then he is in the same situation as before this follow-up letter. So the only reason to reconsider the wand-snapping is that he might not actually be expelled. Thus, this would still fit with the assumption that wand-snapping is a function of expulsion.

When you mentioned in your question that the Death Eaters never had their wands destroyed, for some reason I thought back to what Dumbledore says in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince about Voldemort's early years at Hogwarts, and his group of young followers budding Death Eaters :. So, this might explain why the Death Eaters never had their wands confiscated or destroyed when they were at school, at least - they were never caught.

I'm not sure whether you thought about the Death Eaters' school years when you were writing your question, but Because Hagrid was technically expelled for committing murder.

Why would they give a so-called murderer a weapon? Also, the ministry wouldn't want a barely trained magician on the loose, Why do you think they invented the trace in the first place. Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group. Create a free Team What is Teams? Learn more.

Why Was Hagrid's Wand Snapped? Ask Question. Asked 8 years, 11 months ago. Active 5 months ago. Viewed 10k times. No Death Eater character that we know of was banned from using magic, despite their crimes and devotion to Voldemort. I don't recall any Death Eater wands being snapped and the owner banned from performing magic after being convicted of Death Eater crimes please do correct me if I'm wrong. For example, Bellatrix Lestrange's wand was not snapped in Goblet of Fire when she received a life sentence in Azkaban and, as we know, her wand played a fairly significant part in Deathly Hallows.

Improve this question. Slytherincess Slytherincess k gold badges silver badges bronze badges. The Weasley twins did complete Hogwarts. They passed their OWLs at the end of their 5th year. Compro01 -- That would probably be addressed in Order of the Phoenix. I'll check it out. Add a comment. Active Oldest Votes. And Why was he banned from performing magic? That is okay, because the children won't go out murdering people.

One gets the feeling that Hagrid, in his unscientific way, is trying to teach the class how to determine the characteristics of a hitherto unknown species. He will later, with the only somewhat willing assistance of the class, study their activity over a longer period, attempt to determine whether they want nesting boxes in which to hibernate they do not , and give them exercise by having the students walk them on leashes which becomes difficult as the Skrewts become as large as the students.

When the delegation from Beauxbatons arrives, Hagrid is given the task of caring for the horses. Shortly after this, the Trio visit Hagrid, and find that he has apparently become besotted with Madame Maxime , the Headmistress of Beauxbatons; he has tried to comb his hair with little success, and slick it down with something like axle grease.

They talk about the Skrewts, and also about the upcoming tasks in the Tournament. Hagrid apparently knows something about the tasks, but unusually he does not divulge what is in store for the Champions.

As they prepare to return to the castle for dinner, Hagrid rather overdoes the eau de cologne, and goes outside to wash it off in the rain barrel. Seeing Madame Maxime leading her pupils up to the school, he goes to join her, apparently forgetting all about the Trio still in his hut. After Harry's name comes out of the Goblet , Hagrid asks if he has any idea who put his name in.

Harry is very relieved that Hagrid believes he did not put his own name in, but is unable to venture any guesses. Harry, to avoid the taunts he is receiving, is under the Invisibility Cloak. Seeing Hagrid in the Three Broomsticks, he waves, then realizes that Hagrid can not see him; Professor Moody , who is with him, can see him, however, and brings Hagrid over to Hermione's table.

Hagrid then asks Harry to bring his cloak to Hagrid's hut at midnight that night. Harry, who has an appointment to speak with Sirius Black at 1AM, decides that he can just make it. Hagrid tells him to put on his cloak and follow, then knocks on the door of the Beauxbatons carriage and asks Madame Maxime to accompany him. Harry wonders exactly what it is that Hagrid expects him to see, but is alarmed when Hagrid and Madame Maxime walk around the end of the Forbidden Forest to a corral in which there are four Dragons.

Hagrid is entranced: they are beautiful. Charlie Weasley , one of the wizards there to manage the dragons, asks if it was wise to bring Madame Maxime there, after all she has a student who will be in the competition. Hagrid responds that he just thought she would like to see them. Harry, deeply disturbed by the prospect of having to get past the dragons, quietly and invisibly departs. It is when the Skrewts have destroyed their nesting boxes, and Harry, Hermione, Ron, and Hagrid are finishing rounding them up, that Rita Skeeter appears and asks Hagrid for an interview.

Hagrid will later report that, annoyingly, the interview seemed to be all about Harry, and had nothing to do with anything Hagrid was doing.

Hagrid reveals that he is half- Giant , and asks whether it was Madame Maxime's mother or father. Madame Maxime is highly affronted, says that she has no Giant ancestry and is just big-boned, and storms off.

Hagrid, shattered, sits for a while and then shuffles off to his hut. Shortly afterwards, a story appears in the Daily Prophet , that says that Hagrid is half-Giant. The Trio have no idea how Rita Skeeter, who wrote the story, could have learned about Hagrid's ancestry. Hagrid retreats to his hut and does not come out, either to do his groundskeeping duties or to teach. An alternate teacher, Professor Grubbly-Plank takes over teaching Care of Magical Creatures, and apparently does a better job than Hagrid, teaching about Unicorns , and immediately winning over the hearts of the female half of the class.

Draco Malfoy, meanwhile, taunts Harry that the article will have finished Hagrid's teaching career, as many people will be afraid that Hagrid's Giant ancestry will come out and he would eat their children. Hagrid remains closeted in his hut until Hermione, angered by a meeting with Rita during a Hogsmeade weekend , hammers on the hut door and demands entrance. She is taken aback to find that Dumbledore is there, but Dumbledore invites them in for tea, and is quite obviously bracing Hagrid to return to duties.

He tells Hagrid about his brother Aberforth , who was charged with performing unnatural charms on a goat, and how he weathered the resulting press exposure.

As he leaves, he reminds Hagrid that he has not accepted Hagrid's resignation, and expects to see Hagrid at breakfast on Monday, and expects also that he will start his teaching duties again. Hagrid says that his father would not be proud of how he is acting, and shows the Trio a picture of himself and his father.

He then asks how Harry is getting on with the Golden Egg clue for the Second Task , and Harry says he pretty well has it defeated. Somehow, Harry feels particularly bad about having to lie to Hagrid. Returning to his teaching job, Hagrid takes up with Unicorns where Professor Grubbly-Plank had left off. He seems to be trying to show that he can teach as well as she can, and he has captured a pair of foals, much to the delight of Parvati and Lavender.

It seems that he does know many useful things about Unicorns, as well. Harry, looking out the window for relief from listening to Ron and Hermione squabbling, sees Hagrid digging near his hut. Madame Maxime walks over to talk to him, but is apparently rebuffed. The next day, Hagrid introduces them to some Nifflers. He says that they are very often used in mines, as they are attracted to bright objects, and are very good at digging. He has everyone select a Niffler, and promises a prize for the holder of the Niffler that retrieves the most gold from the patch of ground Harry had seen him digging up.

He warns Goyle that it is Leprechaun gold, and will vanish shortly, so there's no point in trying to steal it. In the end, Ron's Niffler has retrieved the most gold, but Ron is pensive. He recalls that he had given Harry a fistful of Leprechaun gold at the Quidditch world cup to pay for the Omnioculars and is upset that Harry had not even noticed it vanishing.

When Harry and Dumbledore return, Krum alone is present. Dumbledore sends for Hagrid, who arrives shortly with his crossbow. Dumbledore then sends Hagrid off to fetch Professor Karkaroff. Karkaroff immediately blames Dumbledore for attacking his Champion, which enrages Hagrid to the point that he pushes Karkaroff up against a tree, only letting him down when Dumbledore orders him to.

Dumbledore then tells Hagrid to take Harry to Gryffindor tower, and asks Harry to remain there until morning. In the preparations for the Third Task, it is mentioned that Hagrid had been responsible for planting and growing the hedges that now fill the Quidditch pitch, and that he would be providing some of the creatures that the Champions would have to face.

Harry, knowing the sorts of creatures that Hagrid is fond of, finds this rather worrying. At dinner before the Third Task, Harry notices that Madame Maxime's eyes are red, and that Hagrid keeps glancing at her. When the third task comes around, Hagrid is apparently one of the marshals, who will be keeping an eye on the maze for distress signals from the Champions. While the other marshals are wearing their red ribbons on their hats, Hagrid has no hat and therefore wears his marshal's ribbon on the back of his waistcoat.

As it turns out, Harry encounters a Skrewt in the maze, so at least some of the challenges are, in fact, Hagrid's doing. As Harry is recovering from his adventures in the maze, he hears argument between Dumbledore and Cornelius Fudge as to whether or not Harry's story can be believed. After he has recovered, and with no Defence Against the Dark Arts classes to go to, the Trio can visit Hagrid more often.

On one such visit, they notice that there are two bucket-sized teacups on the table, and Hagrid confirms that he's been having tea with Madame Maxime. He says that Dumbledore had given him a mission, though he could not talk about it yet, and that he has pretty much convinced Madame Maxime to join him. Hagrid startles Harry by saying that he was pretty sure Voldemort would be coming back one day, that it was only a matter of time.

He goes on to say that Harry had done as well as his father would have, and there's no higher praise than that. Harry smiles for the first time in days. At the beginning of the school year, Harry is deeply concerned that Hagrid has not returned to Hogwarts; his classes are being taught by Professor Grubbly-Plank, and no one will say where Hagrid is or when he will return.

When he reappears well into winter, Harry, Hermione, and Ron secretly visit him at his hut. They are shocked by Hagrid's battered appearance, although he does not initially explain what has happened.

Perhaps this makes him more of a bad employee than a bad friend and certainly a bad teacher! Not Hagrid, who decided that his new posting as the Care of Magical Creatures professor would be a great time to cross-breed illegally and come up with the Blast-Ended Skrewt. From everything known about the Harry Potter universe, it's clear that Azkaban is a truly horrible place to be - somewhere that would drive a witch or wizard mad unless you are Sirius Black, of course.

Dumbledore manages to avoid it himself, by zooming away on Fawkes, but he allows Hagrid to be taken when the Chamber of Secrets was re-opened. Again, Dumbledore knew that Hagrid never opened the chamber in the first place, and at this point had all kinds of sway in the wizarding world, and yet he still didn't prevent this.

Once again, Hagrid is not the only person who gets this treatment from Dumbledore, but it's clear that he is not exactly concerned about making sure that his 'friend' is safe.

Instead, he is constantly putting Hagrid in dangerous situations - often enough to get him killed. It could be argued that Hagrid takes these 'assignments' on of his own free will, but in many ways, this just seems like an abused power dynamic. Hagrid, an orphan, has looked to Dumbledore for protection and care since he was in school. Dumbledore clearly has power over him, as a father-figure and an employer, leaving Hagrid who may well be an alcoholic in a truly vulnerable position, which Dumbledore happily exploits.

More than anything, it's clear that these two aren't really friends because, well, they never really spend any time together. They both live at Hogwarts, and yet the two are rarely, if ever, seen together when not in a professional capacity. Hot Property. Times Events. Times Store. Facebook Twitter Show more sharing options Share Close extra sharing options. By Tracy Brown Digital Editor. Tracy Brown.